14 Comments

  1. Cal Lash

    Once again I enjoyed this excellent history.
    Thank you.
    Jon as I have mentioned before, there were a number of Spaniards living in Phoenix that arrived in the US the late 1800’s and early 1900’s. Many of these immigrants from Spain lived North of Van Buren and South of Thomas and between Central Avenue and 16th street. They owned bars and grocery stores and had elegant to modest homes in what is referred to today as the Garfield area. And today (2016) a few Spaniards still live very close to “downtown”. Even in Willow.
    My point us that most Anglos or gringos took Spaniards for Mexicans. But at the time many Spaniards distinguished themselves from Mexicans. Today they mostly refer to themselves as Americans.

  2. Mike Doughty

    History tells us that the Spaniards were the European conquerors of the native Mexicans.Needless to say that did not endear them to the Mexicans.The Spaniards were as disliked just like the gringos who took the land from the
    Spaniards.What goes around comes around.Now we(Anglos) are being becoming the minority.Ain’t Karma a bitch as the actor said.

  3. Cal Lash

    Mike, even to this day a few Spaniards will remind you they are Spaniards. Few are married to Mexicans, but a number to white Mormons among other gringos.
    When my lady friend that is a Spaniard on both the blood line sides (she has also a Roman appearance) and I go to Mexico her conversations in Spanish with Mexicans denote that she is A Spaniard and occasionally raise some eyebrows.
    South and Central Americans were indigenous folks until the first of the Queens religious marauding murderous Spanish soldiers raped the first native thus bringing about the first Mestizo.

  4. Mike Doughty

    Cal-just finished book on Stonewall Jackson and was surprised to learn that he was stationed in captured Mexico City as a young officer under Winfield Scott.I was surprised that our war on Mexico intruded into the heartland of the country,and was definitely not presented this way in my history classes.No wonder the Mexicans still are resentful of our motives in the hemisphere.

  5. wkg in bham

    @MD re “I was surprised that our war on Mexico intruded into the heartland of the country, and was definitely not presented this way in my history classes.” The heartland of what land – Mexico? US? I thought that history is quite clear that Mexico City was invaded via Gulf Coast – Valpariso I think. I’ve never heard anything different. Our civil war generals (e.g. Lee and Grant) cut their battle teeth there.

  6. Cal Lash

    Wkg, Confederate history books?

  7. Cal Lash

    Wkg, ” cut their teeth”.
    Suggest U watch the opening scenes of 2001.

  8. wkg in bham

    Here’s my understanding of the Mexican War: President Polk trumped up the war for two basic reasons (1) establish the Rio Grande as the Mexican-Texas border and (2) to take New Mexico-Arizona-Cali-Utah-Colorado from the Mexicans. The Mexicans residing in the taken areas retained their land and property. There weren’t all that many and some were very rich. The U.S. withdrew from Mexico proper with the signing of peace treaty. It was a land grab, plain and simple. He did it because he could.
    As an aside he was threating war with Canada/England to settle the Canada-U.S border dispute in the Washington-Idaho-Montana area.

  9. Anyone interested in the Mexican War and this period of American history should read the amazing “What Hath God Wrought,” by Daniel Walker Howe.

  10. B. Franklin

    Another thing they don’t teach in history books is that the “glorious” battle of the Alamo was essentially about slavery.
    The Texicans, most of whom came from the southern states of the U.S., wanted to retain it, and they thought the Mexicans were about to rescind the exemption that allowed it in the area of Mexico that eventually became the state of Texas. Slavery had already been abolished in the remainder of Mexico.
    So the battle for independence of the Republic of Texas was a precursor of our own Civil War.
    Except, this time, the wrong side won.

  11. Bradley Dranka

    Doesn’t Arizona’s current leadership align itself with the states of the old Confederacy?

  12. Bradley Dranka

    And that a lot of the old Confederacy, if they could, would go right back to the old “Stars and Bars.”
    Home is where the heart is, or so they say….

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *